According to everything that I've read, OCS is generally thought to be an older form of Bulgarian, AND OCS is considered to have descended from Proto-Slavic (aka Common Slavic). However, you're first claiming that Proto-Slavic is a mixture of Bulgarian and Thracian and then that OCS is a mixture of Bulgarian and Thracian, then there seems to a problem. First, which one are you really claiming to be a mixture ot Thracian and Bulgarian? Next, in your mind, which predates which -- Proto-Slavic or OCS? According to what you're saying, Bulgarian predates either Proto-Slavic or OCS or both. In any of the three cases, how can Bulgarian be the ancestor of its ancestor?
Andy Howey
Egijus <segijus@...> wrote:
If Proto-Slavic is a "mix" of Thracian and Bulgarian, then whence Bulgarian?
Hello,
Bulgarians have come to Thracia somethere from territory of modern Ukraine or Russia. I ment that Old Church Slavonic language have appeared as mix of Thracian and Bulgarian language. I think Old Church Slavonic have made big influence to modern Slavic languages.
Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Shopping - with improved product search
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.