Re: Side issue: the Yastorf Gubin group

From: george knysh
Message: 56706
Date: 2008-04-04

--- tgpedersen <tgpedersen@...> wrote:

> --- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, george knysh
> <gknysh@...> wrote:
> >
> > Torsten,
> >
> > Do your sources have anything to say about the
> fate of
> > this group in the West?
> >
> >
> Cf.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poland_in_Antiquity
> >
> > Here:
> >
> > "At the time of the Suebi tribal confederation led
> by
> > Ariovistus arrival in Gaul, a rapid decrease of
> the
> > settlement density can be observed in the areas of
> the
> > upper and middle Oder River basin. In fact the
> Gubin
> > group of the Jastorf culture disappeared then
> > entirely, which may indicate this group's identity
> > with one of the Suebi tribes. The western regions
> of
> > the Przeworsk culture were also vacated (Lower
> > Silesia, Lubusz Land and western Greater Poland),
> > which is where the tribes accompanying the Suebi
> > tribes must had come from. Burial sites and
> artifacts
> > characteristic of the Przeworsk culture have been
> > found in Saxony, Thuringia and Hesse, on the route
> of
> > the Suebi offensive."
>
> I take that as a question of what my sources say
> happened to the
> remains of Ariovistus' army after the defeat
> inflicted on them by Caesar.

****GK: Actually no. It's a simpler question. There is
evidence of Przeworsk moving west (Saxony,Thuringia,
Hesse). Is there evidence of a similar kind about
Gubin Yastorf moving west?****

The nearest thing I find is in
> Hachmann, p. 67-68

****GK: See my comments between the lines.****
>

>
> "The history of the Rhine area in the time around he
> birth of Christ

****GK: I was thinking about a slightly earlier
period, but perhaps some notions would apply
anyway.****

> is thus mainly determined by two forces, by the
> imperialism of the
> Roman empire, pushing for expansion, and by the
> developing, likewise
> expansive dynamic of predominantly Suebian tribes.

****GK: Which began in the second quarter of the 1rst
c. BCE****

> Between both
> forces, in Caesar's time

****GK: So roughly ca.60-40 BCE ****

there still remained an
> ethnically
> heterogenous, in certain norms of behaviour
> remarkably static
> population; Celtic, closely related to Celtic,
> Germanic and groups
> related to the Germani belonged to it.

****GK: Four groups. And we were told the intrusive
Przeworkers could be discerned among them. Why not the
Yastorfers? ****

The dynamism
> of the Sueui
> induced movement also in these groups. When the
> Romans, however, took
> up the task of ending the perpetual unrest on the
> Rhine border, the
> Sueui for the most part retreated to the Southeast.
> The force of the
> attack therefore did not hit them, but the
> autochthonous population.
> It was partly scattered and resettled, partly,
> however, they rose so
> determinedly against the Roman attack, that it had
> to be aborted. The
> Romans withdrew to the Rhine border. Now the remains
> of the old
> population could regroup and consolidate. They did
> this without their
> social structure changing essentially.

> That's all I found.

****GK: There is another passage (I'll try to locate
it in earlier translations) about the
all-pervasiveness of the Elbe-Germanic archaeological
culture between Rhine and Elbe in the 1rst c.CE****
>
> I found a passage which mentions, BTW, a fibula
> found in Alsace,
> plausibly connected with Ariovistus' expedition. It
> is Elbe Germanic.

****GK: Now THAT is interesting if accurate. Because
in the time of Ariovistus "Elbe-Germanic" as an
archaeological phenomenon was apparently only located
in its "initial" area, and had not yet spread down the
Elbe.

As for my initial question about the fate of Gubin
Yastorf in the period 60BCE --> There is a form of the
"argumentum a silentio" : Hachmann states that
Przeworsk objects are discernible in Saxony. If the
Gubin Yastorfers spread into the Late Yastorf
areas,they might not be archaeologically discernible.
And there remains the problem of the archaeological
void (apparently) of Ariovistus in Gaul: Przeworkers?
Yastorfers? Elbe-Germanic (only evidence so far?)****






>
>
=== message truncated ===



____________________________________________________________________________________
You rock. That's why Blockbuster's offering you one month of Blockbuster Total Access, No Cost.
http://tc.deals.yahoo.com/tc/blockbuster/text5.com