Re: [tied] Baltic-Slavic disintegration

From: alex
Message: 29643
Date: 2004-01-15

Alexander Stolbov wrote:
> The _Iron Age_ Thracian culture has its roots in Romania indeed, but
> at the moment (or rather during the process) of the Satemic
> disintegration all the Satemic languages - Aryan, Balto-Slavic,
> Thracian, Proto-Armenian and some other - must be neighbours. Thus we
> have either to take Aryans out the west steppes and lead them to
> east, or to take Tracians out the east steppes (or forest-steppes)
> and lead them to west. The latter variant seems to me more realistic.

Alexander, there is no proof for Thracian as being a Satem language
beside some wild guesses. There is absolutely nothing where we know
about the meaning of a certain Thracian word for sure and we can connect
it with a IE root for showing: look , Thracian was a Satem language.
All the people who sustained Thracian should have been a satem language
could not deliver the needed proof which shows that. Just assumptions .
Since you and George speak more about archeological aspect of the issue,
I would like to ask which are the connections(if any) of the Noua
Culture and Villa Nova Culture. Any connection at all?

Alex