Re: [tied] substratum theory

From: Davius Sanctex
Message: 23819
Date: 2003-06-25

 
Just a few comments about "subtratum influences":
 
(1) Really we know poorly many of the languages that were at one substratum of Latin and most of the suposed "substratum influences" are only documented in popular inscriptions many time after the virtual extinction of such languages.
 
(2) In other context, for example that of the split of Spanish varieties in America, we know very well the substrate but only a small portion of the features can be atributed to the substratum. (For example my native tonge is Peninsular Spanish and know Nahuatl and Mexico Spanish, and it is evident that only just a few features that distinguish Mexico Spanish from Peninsular Spanish are atribuable to the Nahuatl subtratum. We can improve the comparation takin into account only Mexico Spanish, Old Medieval Spanish and Nahuatl and we observe that the innovations of Mexico Spanish are highly independent of the Nahuatl substratum [and other possible substrata that I only know partially]).
 
But despite (1) & (2) the "substratum influence" is currently mentioned as one of the main causes of language divergence!
 
Davius S.