Re: When Germani?

From: Joseph S Crary
Message: 9027
Date: 2001-09-04

Tor

Right

looks very q to me as well

Sequani C-kwat

Very primative

Still not Nordic-German

Maybe its like several retentive Latin words

like

quattuor or quinque


>Does that mean that the ethnogenesis (or rather glotto-genesis?) of
Germanic should be put at shortly before that year?<

I think the main move from Sweden began within a few years of the
Cimbric migration south, around 120 BC. A much bigger Nordic-German
move during the period of the Roman-German wars, from roughly 55 BC
to AD 45. At present just a formative theory.

>Did Germanic (as a recently established creole) suddenly spread on
previously Celtic territory? <

I think for the most part yes. I believe the Roman sources document
that the Celt-Germans were so depleted by intertribal wars, wars with
rome, and the migration of populations into the Roman held Rhineland,
that there was a virtual flood of Nordic-Germans from Sweden into
Denmark and northern Germany.

This would explain why there is so little impact of Celtic on
continental Germanic. If the Nordic-Germans had lived side-by-side
with the Celts on the continent for a long time one would expect to
find more evidence in German. For example, the type of similarities
found between Brythonic and Baltic. To me this indicates that
Brythonic-speakers shared a common border with Baltic-speakers at
some relatively recent point in time. This leaves no room for the
Nordic German except in Sweden and points north.

Again must run now

JS Crary

Previous in thread: 9025
Next in thread: 9054
Previous message: 9026
Next message: 9028

Contemporaneous posts     Posts in thread     all posts