Re: Sounds, Symbols, and Spellings

--- "Peter T. Daniels" <grammatim@...>
wrote:

> Steve Bett wrote:
> >
> > > Peter Daniels wrote: Who is Adam Brown, and why
> > > do you identify him as "linguist"?
> >
> > SB: Brown has a degree in linguistis and teaches
> > linguistics and ESL classes in Singapore.
> >
> > > PD: Is the blurb-writer acquainted with French?
> > > Korean? (Which, by the measure that people
> > > criticize English for, is even more
> > > disconnected from surface phonetics than
> > > English.)
> >
> > Brown wrote the blurb that appears on the back
> > cover. I have no idea as to what his language
> > proficiencies are.
> >
> > By the measures of phonemicity that I use French
> > and Korean are much more phonemic than English.
> > There are, of course, many ways to measure how
> > well the writing system represents speech. I am
> > very curious about the one that you use to come
> > up with your counter-intuitive conclusions.
> >
> > One what basis do you conclude that Koren and
> > French are less phonemic than English?
>
> All languages are phonemic.

What are some phonemes of ASL, BSL, or Auslan?

> I referred to surface phonetics.
>
> Are you talking about orthographies that record the
> surface phonemics of a language?
>
> Korean most certainly does not; look at any of the
> examples in Sohn's *Korean*.
>
> And French is as legendary as English for its
> difficult spelling -- which other languages have
> the institution of the "spelling bee"?

I've been under the impression that French spelling
is easy for (native) French speakers and difficult
for foreigners whereas English spelling is difficult
for (native) English speakers, and very difficult for
foreigners.

It has been written that Tibetan outdoes English as
far as separation between spoken and written forms.

Andrew Dunbar.

> --
> Peter T. Daniels
> grammatim@...
>
>
>

http://en.wiktionary.org -- http://linguaphile.sf.net/cgi-bin/translator.pl





___________________________________________________________
Yahoo! Messenger - NEW crystal clear PC to PC calling worldwide with voicemail http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com