Re: [Group Reading] Introduction to Pali 1 (4/4)

From: Ong Yong Peng
Message: 11491
Date: 2007-07-27

Dear Nina,

thank you for the sentence in the passive voice. I will add it to the
solutions.

In addition, can you check which of the two sentences I provided is
wrong. Both are almost similar except that

(a) has ... a~n~ne dhammaa gambhiiraa pa.niitaa ye ...
(b) has ... ye a~n~ne gambhiire pa.niite dhamme ...

The location of ye is not really important, but in (a) 'a~n~ne' does
not agree in case with "dhammaa gambhiiraa pa.niitaa", so I think (a)
is grammatically incorrect. What do you think?

The sentence, according to John (Kelly), is from [D.I.12 - i.1.28]. I
hope someone can look up on it again.

metta,
Yong Peng.


--- In Pali@yahoogroups.com, Nina van Gorkom wrote:

> (a) atthi a~n~ne dhammaa gambhiiraa pa.niitaa ye tathaagato pavedeti
> (b) atthi ye a~n~ne gambhiire pa.niite dhamme te tathaagato pavedeti

N: In Pali mostly the passive form is used. I could suggest:
(c) atthi a~n~ne dhammaa gambhiiraa pa.niitaa tathaagatena paveditaa.
perhaps ye is not necessary.

Previous in thread: 11490
Next in thread: 11492
Previous message: 11490
Next message: 11492

Contemporaneous posts     Posts in thread     all posts