Re: Optional Soundlaws

From: G&P
Message: 66826
Date: 2010-10-29

> I don't know why this seems so hard for some people to

> understand. A change in a sound is no less of a law if it
> has two outcomes.

 

I rather think that if there are two unpredictable outcomes, it’s not a law.  But I have no problem with an incompletely applied law, or one with exceptions due to dialects or some other factor.  I don’t think this is about linguistics, but about the definition of “law”.  So we’re into philosophy.

 

Peter

.