[SPAM] [SPAM] [SPAM] [tied] Re: Latin /a/ after labials, IE *mori

From: alexandru_mg3
Message: 64197
Date: 2009-06-15

--- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, Piotr Gasiorowski <gpiotr@...> wrote:
>
Shall I multiply
> counterexamples? We have *woth2-aje/o- > OLat. voto: > CLat.
> veto:/vetui.
> Piotr


Piotr, from where you know that we have a -h2- here? ...:)

I hope that you will NOT START TO TELL US THAT -h2- HERE is deduced ONLY based on Latin *woth2-aje/o- > OLat. voto: , isn't it?

Because if so (and unfortunately for you it is so :)) your example is a PURE CIRCULAR ONE:

1. is -h2- so -h2-eye- because we have a Latin -o:/-a:re

and in the same time:

2. it belongs to Latin -o:,-a:re- because is -h2-eye-

So you cannot use this example.

Marius