Re: Negation

From: Arnaud Fournet
Message: 61868
Date: 2008-12-04

----- Original Message -----
From: G&P
To: cybalist@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Thursday, December 04, 2008 9:38 AM
Subject: RE: [tied] Negation


>> other things being equal words get shorter and shorter rather
> t>han longer and longer
>If this principle were true, we'd be left with only short words like /u/
>after 200 000 years. but as Latin shows, .

You'll find exceptions in French also (e.g. Latin hodie > French aujourd'hui
> modern "au jour d'aujourd'hui"), and I'm sure in almost any other language
for which we have appropriate records. Btu the basic point is still
correct - in general words tend to get shorter.
The mistake is to think that a strong tendency is a hard-and-fast invariable
rule. Piotr did rightly say "other things being equal".
Peter

===============

I wonder what you are trying to say, Peter.

Things being what they are, people being who they are, all in all, and the
rest being in Plato,
then one can state with utmost certainty that the dogma is the dogma
and the truth is the truth, whatever the truth might be.
Yes, we hold something certain this time.
I'm grateful you wrote that mail.
In this world ridden with a handful of crises, it is reassuring to know that
somebody somewhere knows something true.
This is great news.
Thank you again, Peter.

What is the word for "polar star" in PIE ?

A.