Re: Fw: Dumezil

No. When I agree with scores of "main stream" authors - Macdonell, Wilkins, Bryant or Alfred Hillebrandt. why not with Dumezil?

In fact, his thoughts seem to be not accepted by some mainstream authors. Any way, I can not make any comments about him since I have not read him.

What I have sent you is a link and I asked you to read the article if you have access. I don;t have access to the article and I am trying to obtain the article through other sources.

Kishore patnaik

On Sat, Oct 11, 2008 at 8:25 PM, Arnaud Fournet <fournet.arnaud@...> wrote:

----- Original Message -----
From: kishore patnaik

I have not commented on Dumezil at all, though I may have to comment
provisionally what little I know of him earlier and what I have read of him
in the last two days may not make me agree with him.
If any one has access to the article I have sent to Arnaud, they may kindly
send me a copy of it.
kishore patnaik

============

I have little doubt that you are bound to disagree with Dumezil as he
clearly positions his work within the standard framework.

You have not sent me an article, but a site address.
I suppose many people would be interested in getting the article in full.

Arnaud

=======