--- In
cybalist@yahoogroups.com, "david_russell_watson" <liberty@...>
wrote:
>
> --- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, "alexandru_mg3" <alexandru_mg3@>
> wrote:
> >
> > I think that Wikipedia account better than your above
> > explanation I already posted it before:
> > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marcomanni
> >
> > also "I have asked Border-men for WHO"?
> >
> > This "Border-men" story is a folk-etymology repeated
> > here by Piotr ...there was no clear borders among the
> > Germanic Tribes at that time (if you read Tacitus this
> > appear as a clear conclusions)
>
> Dear Marius,
>
> While perusing Wikipedia don't forget to check out the
> article at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protochronism .
>
> See http://lett.ubbcluj.ro/~echinox/caiete1/23.html for
> more on the origins of Romanian protochronism.
>
> David
1. David, I will not make any direct reference here to you even I
could ....:)
2. Usually before conclusions
1. YOU NEED TO READ FIRST THE ARGUMENTS
2. NEXT TO UNDERSTAND THEM
3. NEXT TO COME WITH SOME CONTRA_ARGUMENTS
-> IF YOU HAVE THEM
4. Next, If ONE OF MINE IS FALSE THAN OK -> I will review it.
But before this -> you need to follow all that path... that I
follow too...
3. Now to clarify the current topic for you:
If you try to link the fact that Romanian MURG as a substratual
word of Romanian is a protochronic invention -> in this case Rosetti
was also a protochronist etc...so you mixed facts with ideologies
here...
Next the issue here, is not at all related to the
Romanian/Albanian murg, that clearly goes together with Baltic
margas/murgs next to Slavic, Celtic and Germanic related words
etc...It seems that this is also not very clear for you.
The discussion here is only how to position the Germano-Celtic
marko- 'horse' that is an isolated word that cannot be easy linked
with something else....
4. So if you want to write something on this topic please start by
answering if :
Marco- in Marcomanni is a Germanic Inherited Word or Not?
I have talked currently Only about this here...
If you cannot answer for instance to this question : is better
not to post links that has no link with this
Marius