Re: e: [tied] Re: Finnish KASKA

Well, let me try to raise my sights:

PA *i, *a, *u = PIE *YA, *A(blautvokal), *WA

PIE *A = *e, *o, or *Ø.

Patrick

==================

I give a couple of words to look at :

PIE *e = PAA *a

A funny word is :
Amalthea "the goat/nymph
"who" nourished Zeus
< H2ml-thé-H2
Arabic ta&mal
(inverted morpheme order ?)
t + &_m_l

PIE *i = PAA *i

PIE has few words
where *i is clearly
a vowel and not avocalic yod.

Dialectal French
isard = mountain goat, chamois
Hebrew &ez "goat"
Arabic ma:&iz "young goat"
Word : *&iz
(Iranian izaena is
from Kartvelian dzixgi)

Another word
is skrt ni:ra "nuit"
with i_a scheme
Arabic layla
Root is *n_y_l

PIE *o = PAA *u

Dog : *kuHon
Berber *q_zh_un

PIE *u/w = PAA *u/emphasis

PAA has reinterpreted *u
as emphasis

Cf Dog word
ku > kw > q

I let you try to refute these examples.

Arnaud

=================