Re: PIE *a -- a preliminary checklist

Richard,

I want to draw your attention as the moderator to this opponent
Arnaud.
===========
"opponent" ??
why not "enemy" ??
Arnaud
==============
It is difficult to overstate how much off-mainstream his Proto-Uralic
is and there is not one proper Uralist around (including me) to
discuss it, because the forum is of course on Indo-European.
Jouppe
============
Why not assert that the study of human genetics
should exclude any study of other living beings ?
ARnaud
===============
If I may ask: should your great effort not deserve a more enlightened
audience than you may get here among simple Indo-Europeanists? It
deserves at least a dissertation presented at a reputable university.
Jouppe
========
Under progress, I hope.
Arnaud
===========
I will comment them below well knowing that Arnaud
will "refute" me, because I am Finnish.
Jouppe
===================
Paranoid ??
Arnaud
===============