david_russell_watson wrote:
> The answer, whatever it is, neither lends anything nor
> takes anything away from your own argument, but which
> wasn't Alex's intent in any case, as he writes above
> "Reverting to a seriously meant consideration", meaning
> that nothing he wrote was seriously intended as support
> for your claims.
that is true. However, just for the rightness of the arguments, there is
indeed an Out of Inda migration which is known to us and this is prooved
by Gypsies as I mentioned.In the same manner, there is too a Invasion in
India known to us and this is the Invasion of Nordic part of India due
Alexander the Great.
We do not know what did happen 1000-2000 years before Alexander the
Great and I doubt there is any chances to find it out. The bad part of
the India as being IE-Homeland is the singularity of the movement. Why
all migrating tribes from India kept going West? It seems more probable
India is just the most far away point reached by IE speaking people in a
radial movement(expting Tocharian which has a more northic point). On
another hand, all migrations known to us are coming from Asia to Europe,
from imemorial times, the only big Migration from West of Europe to East
being that one of the Celts and with in a less importance, the one of
the Germans.( specialy the Goths since the Herules and Bastarnae have
not reached so far as the Goths).
Alex