From: Daniel J. Milton
Message: 41570
Date: 2005-10-24
>rather
> Brian M. Scott wrote:
> > At 8:52:50 on Monday, 24 October 2005, Grzegorz Jagodzinski
> > wrote:
> >
> >> And, have dialectologists problems with counting each
> >> single dialect as French, Occitan aka Provençal,
> >> Catalonian, Spanish or Italian?
> >
> > What about the Franco-Provençal dialects?
>
> French is a langue d'oil while Provençal is a langue d'oc. This is
> generally accepted, so nobody should have problems withFranco-Provençal.
> However, see also e.g.they can be
> http://www.ethnologue.com/show_family.asp?subid=90061. The authors of
> Ethnologue treat Franco-Provençal like a separate language from the
> Gallo-Rhaetian branch. They treat many dialects as languages but
> right in this point (as far as I know, Franco-Provençal isacknowledged to
> be a language in both France and Italy).dialects
>
> "Francoprovençal or Arpitan is a Romance language consisting of
> that can be found in Italy (Valle d'Aosta, Piemonte, Calabria,Apulia), in
> Switzerland (cantons Fribourg, Valais, Vaud, Neuchâtel, Geneva,non-German
> speaking parts of Bern, but not Jura, where the dialects spoken areFrench)
> and in France (Dauphinois, Lyonnais, Savoy).group of
> The language forms a linguistic sub-group of its own between the Langue
> d'Oïl and Langue d'Oc. The name Franco-Provençal was given to the
> dialects in the 19th century as they shared features of French andProvençal
> without belonging to either. Although the name of the language is wellFrench nor
> established, there is some dissatisfaction with it, given that the
> distinguishing feature of Franco-Provençal is that it is neither
> Provençal. The name Arpitan is sometimes used, as are, individually,the
> names of the various dialects (Savoyard ("Savoyan"), Lyonnais, etc.)It is
> now considered an endangered language."l'occitan (ou
>
> (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franco-Proven%C3%A7al_language)
>
>
> "Le francoprovençal ou arpitan, à ne pas confondre avec le provençal,
> constitue l'une des trois grandes langues gallo-romanes avec
> langue d'oc) et le français (langue d'oïl)"
>
> (http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arpitan)
>
> Note also that the Franco-Provençal area do not separate Provençal from
> French all along their border. So, I cannot see problems...