Re: [tied] Re: Albanian connection

From: Piotr Gasiorowski
Message: 6356
Date: 2001-03-05

Zë (Gheg zâ; Gheg nasality is etymological here) is usually taken to be related to Slavic *zvonU (< *g^Hwon-o-) 'ringing sound, bell' and *zvo~kU (< *g^Hwon-ko-) 'sound'.
 
The etymology of Zeus is so well known and so clear (< PIE *dje:us 'Sky God' -- in fact, it's one of the best-evidenced Indo-European words) that any new attempts to "explain" it can only be undertaken by an undaunted amateur who knows nothing about etymology but believes in his ability to reinvent linguistics from scratch. By Zeus, Alvin, you could at least have checked what is already known about the word -- any good dictionary will tell you that! I can't check the etymology of <zot> at the moment, but since Albanian <z> may derive from *dj-, I'd risk the tentative guess that <zot> is a reflex of the contracted vocative *djeu-atta 'Djeus-father' (cf. Albanian at 'father'). I'll try to verify this by tomorrow. Anyway, even if the names Zot an Zeus are related, it's a "sisterhood" relation -- they derive from the same PIE root.
 
Comparing words from different languages at random, just because they seem to sound similar, is not serious etymology. You claim a very special position for Albanian -- as the most ancient language of the Balkans and the source of culturally important loanwords in all the neighbouring languages. I'm afraid nobody except extreme "Albanocentrists" can take this claim seriously.
 
Piotr
 
 
 
 
 
----- Original Message -----
From: Alvin Ekmekciu
To: cybalist@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Monday, March 05, 2001 1:26 PM
Subject: [tied] Re: Albanian connection


I might even speculate that "Zeus" has do whith the "voice" the thunder
brings "Zëu" (Voice, in Albania).
"Zëu, zë, ze, za, zo" = "voice"
In meantime:
"zë, ze, za, zo" stand even for "to catch", as it would be the case "caught
by the thunder !"= "zë rrufeja!"