Re: Odp: Odp: Slavic or Slavonian?

From: Mark Odegard
Message: 994
Date: 2000-01-19

junk Piotr writes:   BTW, there are also Slovenians, Slovaks (who call their country Slovensko) and Slovincians(an extinct ethnos close to the Kashubians in northern Poland).
 
Simona comments: I've been taught that I should call myself and the language I speak Slovene when speaking English. But recently the adjective Slovenian can be seen as well. I don't think it's very common to use it as a noun.

Piotr further responds:

Thanks for the correction, Simona. Of course Slovene is the correct word for an inhabitant of Slovenia. As a brother Slav I should have known better, but I was writing in haste. Nevertheless, Slovenian for the language can be found very often, especially in American sources.



Yes, most Americans would say 'Slovenian' as the adjective and noun for the nationality and language. We Americans need to be reminded what other peoples prefer to be called in English; sometimes, though, as with any language, moving us to the 'preferred' word is a lost battle.

For myself, I treasure the name Carniola. This is what Franz Joseph called what is essentially modern Slovenia. Carniola is as redolant of exotic Middle European places as is Transcarpatian Ruthenia, Eastern Rumelia or Bukhovina, to mention just a few.

Mark.