From: Peter T. Daniels
Message: 6269
Date: 2005-10-12
>[the attribution of this question is lost in the mists of snippage]
> --- In qalam@yahoogroups.com, "suzmccarth" <suzmccarth@...> wrote:
> >
> > --- In qalam@yahoogroups.com, "Richard Wordingham"
> > <richard.wordingham@...> wrote:
> > > One thing that is troubling me is the division of Indic scripts.It is primarily geographic, of course. WWS has separate sections for
> > > Can
> > > the division between South Asian and South East Asian scripts be
> > > anything but a geographical division.
> > Legacy standards? or is there a difference because of the differenceBengali and Oriya are one subgroup, Devanagari and Gujarati the other,
> > in language families?
>
> There are two historical differences. There's a division between
> North Indian and South Indian scripts, and a difference between Indic
> languages and the rest. There are also hiddden issues because
> Devanagari was taken as the Indic language exemplar - Bengali might
> have been better.
>
> I'm not sure that Bengali is closely related to Devanagari - Bengali
> has <e> on the left and split vowels for <o> and <au>. In these
> respects it is like the South Indian scripts.
> > That is why Tamil is so differentLanguage family has nothing to do with it. The other three literary
> > from other Indic scripts. It is from the same *script* family
> > historically but there are so many conceptual differences. The
> > concept of how the writing system works seems to vary from the Indic
> > language family considerably.
> Not really. There is a problem in that the Tolkappiyam does notWhy would you want to unify a bunch of scripts with diverse origins used
> relate to the Indic script scheme, but that is about it. The main
> points are that having largely simplified the system by eliminating
> most conjuncts, it is then complicated by consonant-vowel ligatures,
> and the handling of stacks is trivial in Tamil.
>
> I wasn't joking when I suggested that visual Tamil could be handled as
> a variant of Thai.
>
> This doesn't help my search for a concept unifying SE Asian scripts.