Anomalies in the suttas?

From: k_nizamis
Message: 2895
Date: 2010-07-18

Dear friends,

in the course of my study and research (focussed mainly on the Suttanta Piṭaka) I'm encountering what seem in one way or another to be 'anomalies' - or at least 'surprises' - in some of the texts.  I'd like to inquire about some of these, because there is a question here about whether, and how, some texts should be at least temporarily 'bracketed' because of such anomalies, in comparison to others, even within the Suttanta Piṭaka.  That in itself is obviously a deep question and problem: I'm not ready to tackle that one, but fortunately, it doesn't really affect what I'm primarily working on.

The first example, which I'll put in this post, is a very small one, but still rather peculiar.  Has anyone come across any further textual 'evidence' that would support (or categorically refute) what 'seems' to be the 'obvious' sense of the following:
SN IV.2.2.1 Rahogata Sutta (36.11; PTS S iv.216) has:

atha kho pana, bhikkhu, mayā anupubbasaṅkhārānaṃ nirodho akkhāto.  paṭhamaṃ jhānaṃ samāpannassa vācā niruddhā hoti.  dutiyaṃ jhānaṃ samāpannassa vitakkavicārā niruddhā honti.  tatiyaṃ jhānaṃ samāpannassa pīti niruddhā hoti.  catutthaṃ jhānaṃ samāpannassa assāsapassāsā niruddhā honti.  (etc.)

(A quick search on the wonderful DPR shows a repetition of this formulation in A iv.409, and Abhi 5.2.2.(14)5.)

It's the last sentence in this quotation that I'm curious about: "catutthaṃ jhānaṃ samāpannassa assāsapassāsā niruddhā honti."  Am I to understand, here, that in the fourth jhāna, inhalation and exhalation cease??

Even internally to the doctrine itself, let alone more mundane practical reasons, this seems strange, because of the fact that it is usually stated that breathing stops during saññāvedayitanirodha: i.e., the  kāyasaṅkhārā are the first to cease upon entering saññāvedayitanirodha.

I will look at the commentary, next, but I'm curious to know how the more seasoned deal with such seeming 'anomalies'. 

Metta,
Krhistos






Next in thread: 2900
Previous message: 2894
Next message: 2896

Contemporaneous posts     Posts in thread     all posts