Thanks Nina for the explanation


The commentary to the Vitthatasutta (AN 3.002) says:

udayatthagaaminiyaa ti pa~ncanna.m khandhaana.m udayavayagaaminiyaa udaya~nca vaya~nca pa.tivijjhitu.m samatthaaya. pa~n~naayaP samannaagato ti vipassanaapa~n~naaya ceva maggapa~n~naaya ca sama"ngibhuuto.
"endowed with wisdom" means the state of being endowed with the wisdom of the path and the wisdom  of insight. "Leading to rise and fall" means - which (wisdom) is able to discern both rising and falling leading to the (discernment) of rising and falling of the five aggregates.

Metta, Bryan



________________________________
From: Nina van Gorkom <vangorko@...>
To: Pali@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2011 10:21:56 AM
Subject: Re: [Pali] udayatthagaaminiyaa paññaaya samannaagato


 
Dear behappydfgt,
Op 12-sep-2011, om 12:49 heeft behappydfgt het volgende geschreven:

> udayatthagaaminiyaa paññaaya samannaagato
>
> It appears at AN 8:54 on paññasampaada, I have seen it somwhere
> else but now I cannot recollect properly.
>
> It refers to the udayabbayañaan·na, or it refers to a reflective
> understanding of impermanence in the world of concepts.
>
> What the commentators said?

-----
N: The stage of insight realizing the arising and falling away of
dhammas is the first stage of Principal insight, Mahaa-vipassanaa
~naa.na. It realizes the arising and falling away of whatever reality
appears at the present moment. It is not mere thinking, and it is not
thinking in general of the impermanence of people and things in the
world. Insight is direct realisation, not thinking.
Gaamin: leading to. Endowed with pa~n~naa leading to rise and fall
(udayattha, as given in PED).
-----
Nina.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]