There seems to be some confusion concerning what can be expected from the
act of writing and posting one's individual work.
Sarah Bowen writes:
*****************************************************************
Whilst I wholeheartedly agree with Daniel, Laurel and Jennifer that it would
be great to have some beginner level translations being posted as well as
the more scholarly stuff, I'm not sure that it's wise for people whose first
language is not Icelandic or a mainland Scandinavian language to try and
write Old Norse themselves. As Arlie pointed out it is very hard for
'foreigners' to produce something 'native-sounding' and we might end up
learning one another's mistakes rather than learning from them
*****************************************************************
It would be foolish (i.e., not wise) for anyone to suggest that we can gain
reasonable translation experience in ON by reading the awkward writings of
beginners!
The benefit to be expected by beginners posting their own writing is not to
be gained by READING the exercises of others so much as by WRITING one's
own. If you sit down to write something in ON, you have no choice but to
make an attempt to THINK in the language. Naturally, we are doomed to
failure - but the reward is in the doing - not the having.