Re: Substrate language which contributed sarSapa to

From: shivkhokra
Message: 71535
Date: 2013-11-10

Dear Jyothibabu,

    You are putting words in Bhadriraju's mouth. Please show us with a proper reference where he comes up with derivation of Sarson (mustard) that you invented.


    If you cannot show us a reference from any of Bhadriraju's works then I am afraid my assertion stands that you are overlooking / mis interpreting what Krishnamurthi wrote.


Regards,

Shivraj




---In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, <jyoti585858@...> wrote:

Shivraj wrote:

> You may have overlooked Bhadriraju Krishnamurthy because
> he said exactly the same thing that I wrote.

Did Krishnamurti himself “overlook” what he said? I am sure
he didn’t. Then why did he spend time and energy researching
on Proto Dravidian ‘k’ and ‘c’, after stating that?

> In general any hypothesis should be testable with data. In
> the current discussion I provided the data which you could
> not refute so you must look into whether your hypothesis
> is correct or not.

I have no need to refute that data. I know and may others in
the list know that the data you provided is irrelevant to my
hypothesis. Many members in the list are familiar with Indo
Aryan and Dravidian languages and their relationship.

-Jyothi