Re: Substrate language which contributed sar

From: Lalit Mishra
Message: 71470
Date: 2013-10-29

From: "jyoti585858@..."
To: cybalist@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, October 29, 2013 9:04 PM
Subject: RE: Re: [tied] RE: RE: Substrate language which contributed sar

---In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, wrote:

[...]

>> There has been no Dravida language in the times Vedas were being re-organized,

> There were many languages including Dravidian languages and Rshis were wise
> enough to borrow from them.


I see, you are omitting the evidence provided to you and to rest people  that Vedic God Agni
is called Dravida in Vedas, There has been no seperate Dravida language or seperate
Dravida entity in the Vedic Age as far as Vedic Hymns are concerned,
Dravida is a wrong
hypothesis originated and imposed on students and common people without proper study of
historical aspect of Sanskrit in Vedic Age, you should counter argue to arguments and evidence
provided before jumping to post.
 
> Many thing will become clearer if the origin of many ordinary words in north
> Indian languages are studied more closely

In the Rigveda Vedic Rishi explains making of Sanskrit words from the sound made in
the nature, this one important citation thats completely missed by western intelligentsia,
very crucial
 among other reasons given in Nirukta for knowing the making of words and
understanding their roots,.misinformed scholars indulged in studies happened to adopt wrong
methodologies without clue and obviously could not study Vedas well, otherwise, they could
understand that most of linguistic guesswork such as presence of Non Sanskrit Words is
nothing but a reflection of void in studies, even the most brilliant work suffers due to issues in
methodology adopted with respect to Sanskrit and Vedic Age History.
 
Can you and other friends of yours, show what was the Dravida language existing in the Vedic Age,
You have to put textual and historical evidences of existence, feel free to contact your well wishers
in India and West.

Its clear that unnless western intelligentsia corrects flaws made into studies of Vedic Age History
in the last 150 yrs, a group of Indians copying western intelligentsia wd not begin self correction
since every act of copy makes them feel that they are growing in real of science.

[Reformatted for readability. -BMS]