Re: Hindu noise-makers, Elst and OIT -- a review of book by Harald

Then he is a Vedic Scholar and You should beg his pardon

2013/10/19, shivkhokra@... <shivkhokra@...>:

> Vedic scholar or a scholar of any other language be it Greek or Russian or
> whatever ought to be able to read the language natively as in have the
> ability to read primary sources and understand its Grammar.
>
>
> They should know what is written in multitude of texts of that language.
>
>
>
> ---In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, <cybalist@yahoogroups.com> wrote:
>
> Please give us a definition of "Vedic Scholar" and I'll tell You
> whether Dr Brighenti fits in or not.
> For Your information, I side with the Theory that Indo-Aryan in
> indigenous both in India and outside it and that every other
> Indo-European language class is indigenous in the area of its first
> records, so that Proto-Indo-European was the language of the first
> Homines sapientes in each of these areas. To my eyes, both AIT and
> Aryan-Invasion–from-India-Theory emanate from the same prejudice -
> Short Glottochronology
>
>