Re: IE finite verb forms as non-finite ones

From: G&P
Message: 67284
Date: 2011-03-28

Tac. Germ. 46
'Peucinorum Venethorumque et Fennorum nationes Germanis an Sarmatis ascribam
dubito'.
"I am in doubt whether to ascribe the nations of Peucini, Veneti and Fenni
to the Germani or to the Sarmatae".

Torsten suggests: "The phrase before 'dubito' would traditionally be
analyzed as a dependent clause serving as object of dubito; one could
instead understand the finite (subjunctive 1sg pres.) verb form 'ascribam'
as a finite, but inflected one (participle, 1sg pres.).

I suspect Torsten may wish to reword that. It makes no sense, and perhaps
he has not expressed his real meaning. (And I can't work out what that
would be.)

The traditional interpretation of the Latin is unavoidable.
Peter

Previous in thread: 67283
Next in thread: 67285
Previous message: 67283
Next message: 67285

Contemporaneous posts     Posts in thread     all posts