Re: Five questions about H. Rix et al.'s _LIV_

From: G&P
Message: 66497
Date: 2010-08-29

>> 5) It doesn't matter how many "laws",

>The point here is that if there are too many chanɡes, the evidence won't be able to support them well.

 

I think the article assumes that one PIE root is one piece of evidence, which can support one sound law at most.  That is absurd.  As you suggest, it is correspondences, and the number of them, that matters.  And one root can participate in more than one correspondence.

 

Peter


Previous in thread: 66496
Next in thread: 66498
Previous message: 66496
Next message: 66498

Contemporaneous posts     Posts in thread     all posts