Re: Celtic Tanarus and Gmc Thunaraz

--- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, Anatoly Guzaev <anatoly_guzaev@...> wrote:

>
> AFAIK, Matasovic is a native speaker of Serbo-Croatian and I wonder why he didn't mention the Serb.-Cr. udaranje "batting, beating, throb, hitting, kicking" (Russ. удар 'strike). Also, it seems that there is the Serb.-Cr. word tandaranje (noise, uproar) which may perhaps be compared to English thunder.
>
> To: cybalist@yahoogroups.com
> From: xthanex@...
> Date: Wed, 25 Mar 2009 12:18:55 +0000
> Subject: [tied] Re: Celtic Tanarus and Gmc Thunaraz
>
> Any ideas on whether Taran and Thunder share a common IE root
> (whether that root be *taron- [per Nikolaev and Starostin] or (s)tene- [per Matasovic] )?
>
>

Anatoly,

Thank you for the input, I'll file it away as possible cognates of the PCeltic *tonaro- & *torano-.
Any personal opinion on who you think may be correct? (Nikolaev and Starostin; Matasovic; or Pokorny)?

Sincerely,
Aydan