Re: Deutschland vs. Sakartvelo

--- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, Przemys³aw Ziobrowski <pmva@...>
wrote:

>
>
> Young powkonar Przmysaw ta nugatu-r:
>
> > I would locate proto-Germanic in the barycenter of Proto-URalic,
> > KArtvelian, Yenissei, Tibetan and Tocharian.
>
> Where's this center of gravity specifically? Is location of the PG
> homeland a secret?

=======
I suppose you can figure it out on Google.
Arnaud
=======

> >>> zoGwa >> zGar "sea" > sajwa
>
> >> Proto-Kartvelian >> Mod. Georgian zGva > Proto-Germanic -- the

only example worth mentioning

>
> > How do you account for it ?
>
> I don't have explanation. I just like it, somehow.

======
Great.
Arnaud
========

> You don't get sarcasm, do you? For the second time: _zGap'ruli_

means

> 'fantastic, improbable'.

=======
Sarcasms are usually negative.
You mean your hedgehog is fantastic.
Great news.
Arnaud
========

> This "probably" cames from the ToB where the root is given as *_(s)

a-xl_.

> If Klimov or Fähnrich (or whoever made that reconstruction) hadn't

doubts

> about that, he wouldn't use the parentheses (and the hyphen). If

you wanna

> refute it, be my guest.

========
what's the reason to use the KArtvelian root instead of using the
Georgian real word ?
Arnaud
========