Re: Ban all non academic discussions

On 2008-04-19 14:39, Kishore patnaik wrote:

> Let us assume that I post on dating on MBh, saying that the event
> has occured in 3000 bce, there is not a single post that logically
> discusses the acceppted main stream thoughts - no one even discusses
> the language and dating of composition of MBh (which is obviously
> much much later to the event itself!)

I don't think anyone here will be willing to discuss such things. I
won't, for one, just as I wouldn't discuss the geography of Atlantic
(though Plato's description of it is in Ancient Greek, i.e. an IE
language). They might allow you to discuss such fantastic chronologies
on lists devoted to Indian Culture, here they qualify both as crank
scholarship and as off-topic stuff.

Piotr