From: fournet.arnaud
Message: 55174
Date: 2008-03-14
----- Original Message -----
From: Patrick Ryan
***
PIE did not have a *z-phoneme, only [z] as an allophone of *s.
***
Let me just amend your statement.
So far, standard orthodox PIE has no *z.
PIE actually had *z and *dz.
But this is not *yet* understood.
Arnaud
===================
***
I have checked Faulkner and Wörterbuch: no <ssb> or <szb>.
You appear to be full of Vycichl.
***
I don't especially think Vycichl is reliable.
But this statement is about as patalable
as one of your previous mails about
Ms. Olsen.
It's quite unbelievable
you *never* can't find a word
in a dictionary.
You have stated you studied in
some famous university in Chicago.
http://www.newton.cam.ac.uk/egypt/beinlich/beinform.html
you write ssb
then you get m-ssb-t Nadel = needle.
Arnaud
==========