> Are you aware
> that
> h is any IE language
> other than Anatolian
> can *never* correspond
> to PAA or semitic H ?
>
> Arnaud
***
A little misleading, Arnaud.
PIE *H, the "laryngeal", corresponds to PAA *?, *h, *H, and occasionally *¿.
Patrick
============
I was talking about cases of actual -h- in Germanic
or other IE languages.
And PIE *H has more phonetic values than you think
as already stated :
*z *dz *s? *ts? *dh? are *H2
*&(ayin) is not at all occasional.
I can see you haven't made any progress....
Arnaud
==============