Re: Re[4]: [tied] Re: *a/*a: ablaut

> >As regards the word house
> >Egyptian has short *e = PAA *a
> >in *paruw "house"

ARnaud
=========>

> PAA /r/ gives Egyptian /3/, Egyptian /r/ comes from /l/, so
> there can be no connection with Anatolian *pé:r, *pr.nás
> (Pre-PIE **pí:r-an).

Miguel Carrasquer Vidal

> =======================

Allow me to express a different point of view.
Both Egyptian <3> and <r> derive from PA(A) /r/.
Patrick
=============
Agreed !
PIE *per / *pr.nos "house"
clearly is a cognate to
Egyptian *paruw "house"
Arnaud
============