Re: Economic analysis of Indian History: meaning of Aryan

It is just too bad that people are growling at me, just when I have commented to a linguist off list that you guys were exasperated at my Mayans' theory but you handled it with magnanimous patience two days ago !!!!

K

On Feb 12, 2008 3:41 AM, kishore patnaik <kishorepatnaik09@...> wrote:

You make me laugh, really.

Yes, I have come here for a definition that suits my needs, But that is because I respected the erudition of the people here. I can not see what is wrong with it. I have a sociological theory of early Aryan tribes and I thought linguistics is one way that supports my theory and whatz more, it can clear some of the confusions that still exist. oh well, it has got  nothing to do with your out of India theories, thank you so much!

If I thought meanings can be made up, I am intelligent enough to make up one( in fact, I already suggested the connection of Arya with Iron and Gold , which seems to be wrong any way) I don't need to ask the linguistics.

In any case, I did not mean to act rude or whatever or hurt any one.  In fact, it is one member who has given me uncivil reply at one point of time in an earlier thread and I suitably replied him. It ended there, so far as I am concerned.  I don't care and don't remember who the member was. It does not suit my purpose of being here. On the other hand, I was egging on you to give me what I want without much further personal discussion since it does not take us anywhere.  If that has smacked of some impatience, yes, it was needed at that point of time.

My stand is very clear. I don't want to get personal here on the group. If some one wants to fight me or make friends, my mail id is  known to every one I guess.

Kishore patnaik