Re: [tied] The idea of the root *h1eg^ ("I", "to speak")

From: Richard Wordingham
Message: 46582
Date: 2006-11-14

--- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, "alexandru_mg3" <alexandru_mg3@...>
wrote:

> A long time ago, a part of their ancestors headed for north and gave
> birth to modern Nilotes, which is evident from the presence of a
> subclade A3b2 in East Africa.

It's very tempting to compare gender in Central Khoisan with IE and AA
- see Alscher's discussion at
http://www.dabis.at/Anwender.htm/Alscher/afroasia.htm . However,
Starostin managed to convince himself that Central Khoisan was related
to Northern and Southern Khoisan, but not, for example, to the East
African languages sometimes lumped in with Khoisan (e.g. Sandawe).

However, this is pushing things so far back that the discussion really
belongs on a Nostratic list rather than on an Indo-European list.

Richard.