Re: [tied] Re: Black Athena: The Afroasiatic RootsofClassicalCivili

From: P&G
Message: 44898
Date: 2006-06-07

Alas, in the development of Greek I do not see many of the changes that you claim have occurred after contact with Semitic peoples..
 
You mention:
 
> -Definite article
Greek had the definite article 1500 BC.  This is a bit earlier than the contact you seem to suggest.  At least a thousand years earlier.
 
> -Preprositions instead of cases or postpositions
Greek retained its cases in the katherevousa, and still has three (or four depending how you count) in the demotike.
 
> -Two genders - masculine and feminine
Greek retains three genders.
 
> -Word order: SVO/VSO instead of old IE SOV.
Here is the only change which occurs as you say, at the time you suggest.  Unfortunately, we have a good guess what caused it - see G Horrocks "Greek: a history of the language and its speakers" page 59-60.  Though there is still debate, and you could put your theory forward.

> -Attributs after their head
The natural place of an adjective in modern Greek is before the noun, not after.  Same in Classical.
    o oraios antras  = the handsome man.

> -Loss of flexional comparative and
superlative,
Greek retains the flexional comperative, and the superlative is based on it.
 
There just seems no evidence, Aquila, for what you suggest.
 
Peter


Previous in thread: 44897
Next in thread: 44899
Previous message: 44897
Next message: 44899

Contemporaneous posts     Posts in thread     all posts