--- "Joao S. Lopes" <
josimo70@...> wrote:
> Does it mean that in Celtic the shift *gWH >gH>g
> occurred before the labialization of the
> labio-velars?
>
> Time 1: k g gH kW gW gWH
> Time 2: k g gH kW gW
> Time 3: k g kW gW
> Time 4: k g kW b
>
> ???
"Brian M. Scott" <
BMScott@...> says:
Proto-Celtic:
Time 1: k g gH kW gW gWH
Time 2: k g gH kW b gWH
Time 3: k g g kW b gW
Time 4: k g g kW b g
Irish: k g g k b g
Welsh: k g g p b g
Sean Whalen <
stlatos@...> says:
Proto-Celtic:
Time 1: k g gH kW gW gWH
Time 2: k g gH kW b gWH
Time 3: k g g kW b gW
Irish: k g g k b g
Welsh: k g g p b gw
That is, I say PC had both kW and gW and each had
different outcomes in Q- and P- Celtic branches.
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com