[tied] Re: Of cows and living

From: tgpedersen
Message: 43523
Date: 2006-02-22

--- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, Piotr Gasiorowski <gpiotr@...>
wrote:
>
> On 2006-02-21 16:51, alexandru_mg3 wrote:
>
> > Why to exclude a PIE *melk(') with k(') for the Germanic words
(see
> > Slavic *melk-o) ?
>
> Because of Grimm's Law. PIE *k(^) becomes Germanic *x (h), which
may
> then become *g if originally preceded by an unaccented syllable.
For
> example, something like *mélko- would have become PGmc. *melxa-,
and
> something like *ml.k(^)ó- would have become PGmc. *mulga-. The
actually
> attested Germanic forms (*melk-/*mulk-) perfectly match Lat.
mulgeo:,
> Gk. amelgo: and Skt. {mr.j-}, as well as the Slavic root *melz-
and
> Lith. mélz^-/mi`lz^- 'to milk'; it's the Slavic noun *melko that
is the
> odd man out, most plausibly explained as a loan from a non-satem
dialect
> with *k from *g^. Only Germanic meets that description, and what's
more,
> Germanic has just the right noun with the right meaning. That
> practically clinches the case.
>

You wish. As a good attorney you should establish motive. What would
be the reason for Germanic milk export at that time?


Torsten