Ringe around the Rosie

From: Patrick Ryan
Message: 43419
Date: 2006-02-14

I am presenting Ringe's opinions (in his own words) under protest since I believe it is the duty of those linguists who constantly prate learnedly about "chance resemblances" to present the case for it � not just hint darkly about what Ringe has "proved".
 
I will do this by providing this link:
 
http://www.tlg.uci.edu/~opoudjis/Work/ringe.html
 
Before I waste my time critiquing the views Ringe expresses in it, I would appreciate it if
 
Andy Howey
 
would inform me if this is an adequate presentation of Ringe's views (one version, anyway � he has changed them many times), and let me know if this is what he had in mind when he forced this on me.
 
If it is, I will attempt to show why Ringe's views (as expressed in that interview) should be vehemently opposed.
 
***