From: Brian M. Scott
> From: Brian M. Scott<mailto:BMScott@...>[...]
> To: mkelkar2003<mailto:email@example.com>
>> "LUIGI CAVALLI-SFORZA: When we took all the (genetic) data
>> from American natives, they clearly fell into three
>> classes, and they correspond exactly to the linguistic
>> families that have been postulated by Greenberg."
> Cavalli-Sforza is not a linguist. (Cavalli-Sforza has in
> fact demonstrated rather startling linguistic ignorance.)
> [snip more non sequitur]
> Cavalli-Sforza has never claimed to be a 'linguist';Kelkar made the claim that 'Greenberg's work on AmeriInd
> nor has anyone, of whom I am aware, claimed that he is
> either. I am sure he does not want to be one!