Re: [tied] The standard IEL tree structure may need reconsideration.

From: glen gordon
Message: 41492
Date: 2005-10-21

M. Kelkar:
> "There are at least two scenarios that might have
> given rise to the peculiar pattern of data
> involving Germanic. One is that the diversification
> of the IE family must be modeled at least in part as
> a network rather than a tree (as discussed in the
> previous section), (p. 52)."

I thought that this was long ago understood. A tree
is merely a loose representation of the
interrelationships of the IE dialects (or, of any
language or language group). It doesn't show
isoglosses well like, say, the distribution of
mediopassive *-r.

Thus the development of the "isogloss map" created
decades ago, which is the "network" that appears to
be sought after in this quote.

Who are these people? COBOL programmers :)


= gLeN





__________________________________
Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005
http://mail.yahoo.com