Re: [tied] Re: A New language tree

From: Piotr Gasiorowski
Message: 37770
Date: 2005-05-09

Brian M. Scott wrote:

> I was especially amused by the author's absurd claim that
> labio-velars are unpronounceable. More important, he
> clearly has no understanding of how science is conducted.

Note the general scheme of his phonetic arguments: I, Kazanas, have
tried to pronounce X and failed. Ergo, X is unpronounceable.

Piotr