Re: [tied] Re: Russ. pilĂĄ

>
> On Sun, 21 Nov 2004 13:04:04 +0100 (CET), mkapovic@...
> wrote:
>
>>> Another source of AP 3 in Lith. is, if I'm not mistaken,
>>> Winter's law, which causes length / acute, but does not
>>> trigger Hirt's law.
>>
>>Lith. nĂşogas, Slavic *nag7 (a.p.3/a) fits just fine for instance, cf.
>>Vedic nagnĂĄs, Greek gymnĂłs...
>
> I suppose thta's a typo for a.p. 3/_c_.

Yeah, I seem to make a lot of typos today :)

>>But: PIE *h2egWnos is immobile (~ Greek amnĂłs), Slavic *vygn6 is
>> immobile
>>(~ Vedic AgnĂ­s)?
>
> Perhaps the final stages of Hirt's law coincided with the
> initial stages of Winter's law? Kortlandt also mentions
> initial stress in Russ. ĂŠla, sĂŠla.

Also *beˇgla "ran", *padla "fell" (root acute stress)... The problem of
the clash of Hirt's law and mobility is also seen in the classic example
of *suHnus which is expectedly a. p. 1 in Old Lith. and in dialects and a.
p. 3 is obviously younger there but Slavic *syn7 (a. p. c by Meillet's
law) corresponds to Lith. younger su:nu`s (3) so we could assume that the
variant without Hirt's law could also be old.

Mate