From: tgpedersen
Message: 31178
Date: 2004-02-19
> >>>> If not, your allegations are only wishful thinking speculationsI said "the usual path". That means /us/ > /us^/, /s^/ > /h/ > zero
> >>>> having nothing to do with scientifical approach.
> >>>
> >>> RUKI
> >>
> >> What has that ancient rule to do with OF, a different language
> >> separated by origin and some millenia?!
> >
> > us > us^
>
> So, according to your logical skills, a phenomenon produced in
> slightly different conditions, some millenia before OF and in other
> linguistic groups (that is the shift of PIE alveolar /s/ to palatal
> /s^/ in Slavic) is to account as proof that in OF there should have
> been an intermediate stage /s^/ between /s/ and /h/ denoted by <x>?
> Is that your point?!
>