Re: [tied] Digest Number 1325

From: JOHN BERRY
Message: 20675
Date: 2003-04-02

Without taking sides on the creole/non-creole issue, and bearing in mind that my knowledge of Japanese is 20 years old:

Nominative:  -wa, -ga

Accusative: -o, -ga (direct object of verb "to be" (arimasu)

Genitive: -no

Dative (or essive):  -ni,  or -te (they do it FOR me)

Ablative:  -de or -e

Locative:   -ni (at, or in) (literary form -ni te)

            or -e (to a place)(similar to Finnish essive?)

Instrumental:  -de

The uses of -ni, -de, -te, and -e are complicated and do not correspond exactly to dative, ablative, locative, etc.

Others:    for the use of X =  X-yo

              intended for X = X-muke

In general, Japanese grammar regards these post-positions as particles, under the influence of Chinese grammarians. They could just as well be regarded as case endings, and in that case, there are enough of them to make a Finn very happy!

John


>What are the common nom, acc, gen, dat, abl, loc, instr endings?

Japanese doesn't retain the Altaic case system, that's clear. In this
respect, it can be seen to have adopted an Austronesian grammatical
pattern. However, we may also note French entirely losing Indo-European
declension yet it's not a "creole" and fully IE.


- gLeN



John Berry Associates
Geology & Remote Sensing
5000 Beverly Hills Drive
AUSTIN, TX 78731, U.S.A.
+1-512-452-8068 (Voice)
+1-512-413-9270 (cell)
jlbassoc@...