Re: [tied] greek ethymology of barbar?

From: alexmoeller@...
Message: 13768
Date: 2002-05-26

[Piotr]
The Greeks did not apply the word <barbaros> to foreign shepherds (they kept flocks of sheep themselves, so the occupation was by no means exotic from their point of view) but to non-Greek speakers, foreign languages or names, bird calls and the like. The word seems to derive from reduplicated *bar-bar- meaning 'unintelligible speech
 
[Moeller] I perfectly agree with your point of view. I just suppose that in this keeping flocks of sheep, they meet people persons who spoked difrent languages. We are too far away for beeing able to say exactly "when" and under which circumstances this word became usual in greek(Because later it became a properly adjective meaning a foreign one). I made the connection just because I heard the valachians sheeperds sayng to thier sheeps "b^ar b^ar you sheep," and that sounded very strange to me.Or we know the thracians were the neighbours of the greek. Maybe it is a link or maybe not. It can be rejected it can be adopted or it can became a  subject of searcing..
 
Piotr