Re: [tied] D. Ringe's IE Tree (1998)

From: Danny Wier
Message: 13638
Date: 2002-05-06

From: "Glen Gordon" <glengordon01@...>

> Steve:
> >You can see this tree at http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~histling/

> Old English as a Satem language. That's in no way tabloid-like...
> Mental note: Don't attend any courses at UPenn.

Actually that chart shows that the satem/centum split didn't split across
groupings, since Greek is grouped with Armenian and Indo-Iranian, and
Germanic is grouped with Balto-Slavic. Albanian, which is the only known IE
language that preserves the five-way stop system and therefore is neither
strictly satem nor centum, is not anywhere in the charts!

I've seen a similar grouping drawn as an actual tree with branches curving
every which way, with Armenian curiously at the center, as though it's
closest to the "original" proto-language.

~Danny~