Re: [tied] Likely IE home: India
From: michael_donne
Message: 12086
Date: 2002-01-18
Thanks for the interesting discussion of this issue. I've asked
someone to send me a copy of Hock's paper where he refutes Misra. I'm
putting my money on Hock. :-)
Some questions:
1) Isn't it true that the relation between Iranian and Vedic Sanskrit
is somewhat anomalous since they both have qualities that make them
appear younger and yet older than each other?
2) Mishra mentioned that Romany and other languages reversed
the 'a,e,o' > 'a' direction when they left India. Is this true? What
are some of the other examples?
3) Does the Centum/Satem split argue against an Indian homeland? Is
it even conceivably possible that Centum split off from an original
Satem?
4) What is a good source for the original Mitanni/Kassite/Hittite
documents with a discussion -- in transliteration please. I don't
want to have to learn cuneiform!
Previous in thread: 12062
Next in thread: 12087
Previous message: 12085
Next message: 12087Contemporaneous posts Posts in thread all posts