Re: [tied] Methodology: Throw it out the window, folks

From: Miguel Carrasquer Vidal
Message: 10470
Date: 2001-10-20

On Fri, 19 Oct 2001 23:13:41, "Glen Gordon" <glengordon01@...>
wrote:

>>IEW 343 *e(:)sr(gW), EIEC 71 under *h1esh2r "Cf. the derivative in
>>Lat sanguen (< *h1sh2en-gW-en-)".
>
>Until you can supply me with an abundant list of words ending
>in vocalic /-r/ in Sanskrit, your reconstructions are irrelevant.

They're not *my* reconstructions, they are Pokorny's and Adams'.

About words ending in vocalic /-r./ in Sanskrit: there are none in the
R.gveda, but -/r./ occurs as a final vowel in the Bra:hman.as (in
particular for neuters in -tr.).

The situation in Vedic is as follows:

PIE Vedic

1. *-r. -ar
2. *-r.t -r.t
3. *-r.s -úr
4. *-r.gW -r.k

1. *Heg^hr. > áhar "day"
*h1ouHdhr. > ú:dhar "udder"

2. *yekwr.t > yákr.t "liver"
*k^ekwr.t > s'ákr.t "excrement"

3. G. *ph2tr.s > pitúr "father's"
3pl.pret. *-r. + s > -úr

4. *h1esh2r.gW > ásr.k "blood"