Greek laryngeals

From: tgpedersen@...
Message: 5870
Date: 2001-01-31

I had an idea some time ago. It goes like this:

First the standard version:

1. (Pre..Pre)Greeks had laryngeals

2. Laryngeals do their stuff to vowels and disappear.

3. Greeks meet Phoenicians. Phoenicians have alphabet. Greeks
take alphabet, but since Phoenician, being AA, has laryngeals,
alphabet has three letters too many. Greeks, being Greek and
inventive, use these three for something entirely new: vowels!

Enter TP, slashing dementedly with Occam's razor:

1. (Pre..Pre)Greeks had laryngeals

2. Greeks meet Phoenicians. Phoenicians have alphabet. Greeks take
alphabet. It fits perfectly.

3. Laryngeals do their stuff to vowels and disappear.

4. Now suddenly three of the borrowed letters stand for vowels. The
Greeks have invented vowels (and they didn't even know it)!

What do you think?

Torsten